Your Best Crib Mattress Buying Guide

Finding the best crib mattress for your baby is much like finding the best mattress for any other bed in your home, except the consequences are far more serious if you choose unwisely.


If you select the wrong mattress for your own bed you could suffer some uncomfortable nights, but if you choose the wrong mattress for a newborn baby you will suffer many nights of complete sleeplessness and the safety of your baby could be at risk.

This is why most parents take the time to read crib mattress reviews before they make this type of purchase. You select the crib, bassinet or Moses basket with complete care, so why wouldn't you look for the best crib mattress on the market?

Safety First

The best crib mattress for your home will always be the one that doesn't put your baby's safety at risk. Crib safety starts with purchasing a sturdy crib with four unmoving sides and ensuring it is set up correctly and placed away from windows, blind cords, and other dangers. Once you have that out of the way, use these tips while reading mattress reviews:

1. Measure your crib and then get exact measurements for each mattress you consider buying. Make sure the mattress will fit snugly without gaps around the edges. If you can get even a couple fingers between the crib and the mattress, it is not a safe fit.

2. Make sure the mattress is firm enough for a newborn baby, like the well-known Colgate Eco Classica I.

Adults may prefer mattresses that conform around the body, but babies need firm surfaces to support their bodies.

Some mattresses are firm on one side and softer on the other, so they are suitable for newborns and can be flipped for growing toddlers later on.

3. If shopping for the best crib mattress in a store, look at the seams to make sure they aren't going to split open easily. If shopping online, read mattress reviews to make sure other parents have not experienced split seams.

4. Antibacterial coating comes on some mattress surfaces, such as the much-recommended Sealy Baby Firm Rest. This will reduce the collection of bacteria and germs from spit-up, diaper leaks, and other mishaps that are bound to happen.

5. Crib mattresses should be coated to ensure they are not flammable as well.

Top of page

Comfort Second

Comfortable babies will always sleep better than babies who are uncomfortable.

You don't want a mattress that is so poorly constructed or so cheap that the springs can be felt from the surface. You can now find innerspring mattresses covered with layers of foam as well as crib mattresses with solid memory foam or latex cores.

Foam mattresses can still be just as supportive and firm as innerspring mattresses, but they will add a higher degree of comfort as well. You just have to watch that they are firm enough for a newborn baby sleeping.

Mattress buying tip: higher density memory foam and higher coil counts signify more durable mattresses. Cheaper mattresses tend to be lower in coil count and foam density, which is why you pay less for them!

Top of page

Price Third

The problem with very cheap mattresses is they include lower density foams and/or fewer coils, which means they will wear down and fall apart much faster. You then have to spend more money replacing them then you would have spent to just purchase a higher quality mattress to begin with!

The best crib mattress will almost never be the cheapest one you can find in some local store. It is best to read mattress reviews and determine what the best mattresses are.

So, what if you don't have that kind of time to shop around online? You can still find great deals by reading crib mattress reviews to identify the best crib mattress options for your home. You can then do fast price comparisons online to find the best deal.

Keep the tips listed above in the "Safety First" section as you read mattress reviews and descriptions of different mattresses. Make sure all of the safety points are covered and then consider the materials inside the mattress to determine how comfortable they may be for your new baby.

Top of page